Offsetting carbon emissions in digital meetings
We spent a lot of time reviewing the best ways to offset carbon emissions produced by our online conferences. Our policy on this is to use techniques that are effective at actually removing CO2 from our atmospheres, in quantities, which can be measured accurately so that we know we are offsetting the right quantity.
So far we compensate using the (direct air capture) technology offered by Climeworks. They basically build big vacuum cleaners that are sucking up some air from our atmospheres and storing the carbon dioxide that goes through them. They then pump it underground and within a few years the CO2 reacts with rocks and turns into solid stones that are permanently put off our atmosphere. Skeptical? Climeworks air capture technique works efficiently and is indeed carbon negative as is described in an independent paper. For the carbon storage underground, you can check this Nature paper or the whole ERC project about it called Carbfix.
Another important part of the work is quantifying accurately how much emission will be produced for a given conference, be it a 10 people workshop for a day or a 1000 people conference for a week. For video streaming during the conference, we assume that 40 g of CO2 are emitted per hour per person (international average) (see source on CarbonBrief). Another way to get this number is to take the average electricity consumption per Gb of transmitted data, which is ~0.04 kWh/Gb (which is the average of the range given by the IEA or see Aslan et al. 2017 for a similar value). And then convert it to (Burtscher et al. 2020) the quantity of CO2 emitted using that it is 0.24 kg/kWh (see ref). For 4Mbps (similar to the Netflix average), it leads to 17 gCO2e. Accounting for the electricity consumption of devices, this number goes up by roughly a factor 2 (Burtscher et al. 2020), which is similar to the previous value. We then reduce this value by a factor 2 to account for the difference between the mean bitrate used by Netflix (4 Mbps) and that of our tool (~2 Mbps for the default medium resolution). We then multiply by the time the conference lasts and the number of participants and can work out the final carbon dioxide mass emitted by the virtual conference that needs to be offset.
For conference video storage, we offset their emission over 3 years based on the number of averaged views we could estimate but that will be refined when we have more statistics from our website. After 3 years, the organisers or their company will be contacted to check whether the videos should be put offline (as some more recent conferences on the same field or by the same participants may have already happened) or if they otherwise want to keep on offsetting their produced carbon emissions (if the video is still state-of-the-art).
Finally we convert this mass of CO2 that needs to be offset in money. Climeworks needs 1 euro to offset 1 kilo of CO2 and bury it underground so that every hour of streaming for each participant costs 0.02 € to offset or roughly 0.16 € (or 0.16 kg of CO2) per day. Given this 0.16 € per day per person, you can easily find an estimate of how much your conference will cost to offset. For 100 participants for 3 days, it would be 0.16 € * 100 persons * 3 days = 48 € (to offset 48 kg). But note that if you want the conference to be recorded and hosted on our platform, there will be extra emissions to offset.
You will be given a certificate from Climeworks that shows you the amount we paid to them and how much emission they offset thanks to you. We are open to diversifying the ways we compensate carbon emissions and if you have effective solutions to suggest, please contact us.
Note that we developed a calculator (see here) for you to be able to quantify how much emission your conference will produce (that needs to be offset).
Sources we used to quantify how much carbon should be offset for a given conference:
Shehabi et al. 2014,
Schien et al. 2014,
Andrae et al. 2015,
Aslan et al. 2017,
Park et al. 2017,
Simulate the Carbon Footprint of your Event